Drainage-layer effects depended on the medium. Water-retention measurements alone cannot establish benefits for growing plants.
The paper was published on 25 February 2025. Laong has not repeated the experiment.
An experiment, at a glance.
Water retained after saturation and free drainage.
How growing plants respond to these layers.
Look closer at the two kinds of mix
Organic, loamless mixes
Most layers reduced total water retention in the tested mixes.
Loam-based medium
Most layers had no overall effect. Some model estimates differed.
A reading aid for Avery Rowe’s 2025 paper. The study and its limits are linked below.
Begin with the measurement
A pot can release water through its base and still hold moisture in its growing medium. When someone recommends a drainage layer, ask which part of that behaviour they mean.
What the experiment found
Avery Rowe’s peer-reviewed PLOS ONE paper compared three potting media, four layer materials and two layer depths after saturation and free drainage. Most layers reduced total water retention in the organic, loamless mixes. Most had no overall effect in the loam-based medium.
The research measured water retention, without growing plants. It does not establish better roots, lower disease risk or a particular watering schedule. The models also disagreed about some estimates for the loam-based medium.
Give excess water a route out
For an ordinary houseplant, inspect the container before adding materials. Is there an open drainage hole? Does a decorative outer pot or saucer keep water around the inner pot?
University of New Hampshire Extension warns that stones used in place of external drainage can keep roots too wet. It recommends a container with a hole that lets excess water escape. The same guidance notes that an oversized pot and ageing growing medium can contribute to persistent moisture.
A layer inside a sealed decorative pot creates no exit. A draining nursery pot inside that outer container gives you a way to remove runoff. The moisture your plant needs still depends on the species and its growing conditions.
Make a useful observation
Before changing a pot, record its size, the growing medium, the plant and where it sits. Check it over several watering cycles. Note standing water and whether the medium stays wet; avoid changing the pot, mix and watering routine together if you want to learn which change helped.
These are observation notes, rather than a controlled experiment or a guaranteed remedy. If you are calculating a refill, our potting mix calculator estimates geometric volume; it cannot predict drainage or plant health.
Sources & further reading
- Avery Rowe · PLOS ONE drainage-layer experiment (2025) ↗
- University of New Hampshire Extension · Houseplant winter care Q&A ↗
This founding-edition article was drafted with AI assistance and checked against the sources above. It has not had independent expert review. Read our editorial approach.
